Smt. Raj Kumari & Ors. vs. Union of India
Background
A 60-year-old man died after falling from or near an EMU train; his family sought compensation, claiming he had a valid ticket. The Railway Claims Tribunal dismissed the claim, concluding he wasn't a genuine passenger and had instead been hit while crossing the tracks.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court held non-recovery of a ticket is not conclusive proof against travel, especially with family witness testimony that he had boarded. The Tribunal's "crossing the tracks" conclusion rested on inference, not direct eyewitness proof. Since railway compensation law imposes no-fault liability, the Court set aside the dismissal and remanded for compensation to be calculated.
Lesson Learnt
Families of railway accident victims don't need a physical ticket or a precise reconstruction of the accident: if the overall evidence reasonably supports genuine passenger status, compensation should follow.