Smt. Sushma Tyagi vs. M/s HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company Limited, Through its Director & Ors.
Background
The petitioner's husband and his brother took a home loan of Rs. 50 lakh from HDFC to buy a flat in Greater Noida, and bought a "Home Credit Assure" insurance policy from HDFC Ergo to cover the loan if something happened to them. The policy covered nine major illnesses, including "Myocardial Infarction", which the policy itself describes as a first heart attack. The husband died of cardiac arrest in April 2021, and the insurer rejected the widow's claim, saying cardiac arrest was not a covered illness. The Insurance Ombudsman (a free complaint forum for policyholders) dismissed her complaint in September 2023 after she refused to sign a mediation form, which she said was handed to her blank.
Decision Breakdown
The Court first held that a writ petition (a direct petition to the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution) could be filed against this private insurer, because it performs a public duty by insuring the public. On the main issue, the insurer's own case was that both conditions involve a disruption of blood supply to the heart, and both are commonly called a "heart attack", the same words the policy uses. An insurer that denies a claim must prove the event falls outside cover, and HDFC Ergo had not done so. Applying the rule of "contra proferentem" (an unclear term in a contract is read against the party that wrote it) and the purpose of a loan protection policy, the Court held that cardiac arrest falls within "Myocardial Infarction" here. It also set aside the Ombudsman's award because the Ombudsman had to decide the complaint once mediation failed, and did not. The insurer was ordered to pay Rs. 27,97,445 (the husband's 50% share of the sum insured) with 9% yearly interest from 3 July 2021, plus Rs. 5,08,176 towards the loan interest the widow paid on that share, and the further interest on that portion until payment.
Lesson Learnt
When an insurance policy's wording is unclear, courts read it in favour of the policyholder, and the insurer must prove a claim is excluded. If an insurance complaint forum does not decide your complaint on its merits, that decision can be challenged.