Mohd. Ahmad vs. Union of India
Background
A father claimed compensation after his son, Tehzeeb, died in June 2017. He said his son was travelling from Chandigarh to Rampur on the Chandigarh-Lucknow Express with a valid ticket and fell from the train near Roorkee. The Railway Claims Tribunal rejected the claim in 2020. It found that the son was not a "bona fide passenger" (a genuine passenger with a valid ticket) and that there was no "untoward incident" (the legal term for events such as falling from a train), mainly because a witness gave a ticket purchase time that did not match the railway's computer records.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court set aside the Tribunal's decision. Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Union of India v. Rina Devi, it said the claimant must first show the person was a genuine passenger, after which the burden shifts to the Railways, and the absence of a recovered ticket is not decisive by itself. The Tribunal had treated the mismatch in the witness's timing as fatal without examining the ticket numbers in the railway's own CRIS verification, which showed tickets issued from Chandigarh that day. It also ignored a Railway Protection Force report saying a ticket was seized from the body, and leaned on the railway inquiry report under Section 123(c) of the Railways Act, 1989 without weighing the post-mortem and inquest material. The matter was sent back to the Tribunal, which was asked to assess the compensation payable and have it paid within two months, with the case listed before the Tribunal on 16 December 2026.
Lesson Learnt
A single inconsistency in a witness's account should not sink a railway accident claim when the Railways' own records support the passenger's travel. Tribunals must weigh all the documents together, and once a family shows the person was a genuine passenger, the Railways must answer that evidence.