Mazhar Khan vs. Union of India
Background
Mazhar Khan said he was travelling from Deoband to Delhi on 28 March 2018 on a combined ticket bought for himself and his father. Near Meerut, in a crowded compartment, he lost his balance, fell onto the next track and was hit by another train. He lost one arm and one leg. The Railway Claims Tribunal rejected his compensation claim, relying on a railway enquiry report that said he had got off a different train from the wrong side.
Decision Breakdown
The Court first accepted his request to excuse a 747-day delay in filing the appeal, given his poverty, lack of education, serious injuries and the welfare purpose of the law. On the merits, it applied the Supreme Court's ruling in Union of India v. Rina Devi: a missing ticket does not by itself defeat a claim, and once the injured person gives the basic facts of the trip, for example in a sworn statement, the burden shifts to the Railways. Here the original ticket was on record and the Railways had itself verified that it was issued at Deoband. The Railways' version rested on a statement by a shunting master who was never brought before the Tribunal to be questioned, and Khan was never confronted in cross-examination (questioning by the other side) with the Railways' story about the other train. The Court set aside the Tribunal's judgment, allowed the appeal and sent the case back to the Tribunal only to work out the compensation and have it paid within two months, with the matter listed before the Tribunal on 3 December 2026.
Lesson Learnt
A passenger injured in a train accident is not shut out merely because the ticket was not found at the spot; a verified ticket or a sworn account of the trip can shift the burden to the Railways. A statement from someone who never appears as a witness cannot be the main reason to reject a claim.