D.G. Employees State Insurance Corporation vs. Nandkumar J. Dalvi
Background
Nandkumar Dalvi, an ESIC employee, became totally blind in 1990-92 and was repeatedly rated "Below Average" and denied promotion despite no adverse remarks in his records. The Chief Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities ruled in his favour, finding bias, and ordered retroactive promotion to 1989. ESIC challenged this.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held that assessing promotion suitability is the Departmental Promotion Committee's specialised job, and absence of negative remarks doesn't automatically entitle promotion. It found no concrete evidence the repeated "Below Average" ratings were driven by his blindness rather than genuine assessment: a past instance of bias (since corrected) didn't prove later decisions were biased too. Since Dalvi had since reached retirement age, actual promotion was no longer practical. The Chief Commissioner's order was set aside.
Lesson Learnt
A discrimination finding must be backed by concrete evidence linking the adverse decision to the disability: courts generally won't second-guess a specialised body's performance assessment without clear proof of unfairness.