In Re: XXX, A Judicial Officer in the District Judge Cadre of Rajasthan Judicial Services
Background
Two POCSO trials arising from the same FIR, one against a child in conflict with law, one against an adult co-accused, had to be tried and decided separately by statute. The judicial officer delivered both judgments on the same day, but due to the sole court stenographer being on leave, some overlapping evidentiary details from one trial were inadvertently carried into the other's judgment. On a bail application, a High Court Single Judge sharply criticized the officer, alleging the judgment had been drafted by a stenographer without her reading it, ordered the criticism placed in her annual confidential report, and directed her retraining.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court expunged the adverse remarks and directions, holding they were recorded without giving the officer any chance to explain, violating the principle of natural justice (audi alteram partem). It held High Courts must distinguish between criticizing an erroneous judicial order and attacking a judicial officer's personal conduct or competence: concerns about an officer's conduct should be routed through the administrative side to the Chief Justice, where the officer can respond, not aired as judicial strictures that follow them into their service record. The officer's explanation, overlapping evidence between the two closely related trials and a temporarily unavailable stenographer, resulting in bona fide typographical errors that didn't affect the outcome, was accepted.
Lesson Learnt
A judicial officer facing a clerical or administrative lapse in judgment-writing is entitled to a chance to explain before being castigated in a published order; genuine conduct concerns belong on the administrative side, not as judicial strictures that can derail a career.