Mithilesh Kumar Pathak v. Union of India
Background
A CRPF constable posted in Anantnag, Jammu and Kashmir, was on casual leave until 12 October 2000 but returned only on 19 January 2001, overstaying by 99 days and not replying to two letters asking him to report. He said he had fallen ill with infective hepatitis at his village in Bihar, and produced prescriptions, lab reports, medicine receipts and a fitness certificate. The enquiry officer called these documents fabricated, mainly because they lacked a hospital patient number and seemed written with the same pen, and he was removed from service. A single judge of the Patna High Court quashed the removal, but a Division Bench restored it, saying the single judge had wrongly re-weighed the evidence.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Division Bench ruling and restored the single judge's order. It held that "unauthorised" absence is not automatically "wilful" absence; the reasons for absence and the supporting material must be weighed, and illness can be relevant. Treating medical papers as forged because of the same pen or a missing patient number, without checking with the doctor, hospital or pharmacy, was conjecture, so the courts could interfere even within the limited scope of review of disciplinary findings. The Court also held that removal for a 99-day overstay was grossly disproportionate even after considering his earlier overstays, and ordered his immediate reinstatement with 50% back wages and all other consequential benefits.
Lesson Learnt
An employer cannot brush aside an employee's medical proof as "fake" on mere suspicion; it must actually verify it. Even in disciplined forces, the punishment must be proportionate to the misconduct, and courts will step in when it is shockingly harsh.