MMTC Limited vs. Aust Grain Exports Pty Ltd
Background
MMTC contracted with an Australian company in 2009 to buy a shipment of yellow peas; a dispute arose over delay-compensation and a bank guarantee MMTC had encashed. An arbitral tribunal largely ruled against MMTC and refunded the guarantee with interest; a single judge upheld the award.
Decision Breakdown
The Court rejected MMTC's procedural and compensation arguments but found one real flaw: the tribunal had expressly rejected the exporter's claim for interest on the refunded guarantee (since the contract barred it), yet then awarded that very interest anyway, a direct, unexplained contradiction. The Court struck out only that contradictory portion as severable, leaving the rest of the award intact.
Lesson Learnt
Courts reviewing arbitration awards mostly can't reconsider the arbitrator's weighing of evidence, but will strike out a specific part that directly contradicts the contract and the tribunal's own reasoning.