MMTC Ltd. vs. Chauhan Jewellers & Ors.
Background
MMTC, a government trading company, used to supply gold on credit to jewellery exporters like Chauhan Jewellers. A dispute arose over five 1990s export consignments with delayed, unpaid, or unreturned-and-uncollected goods; MMTC claimed about Rs. 57.7 lakh. An arbitral tribunal rejected all of MMTC's claims and ordered MMTC to return title deeds held as security; a single judge upheld the award, and MMTC appealed.
Decision Breakdown
The Division Bench upheld rejection of three of the five claims but set aside the rejection of two. For one consignment, the tribunal had wrongly analyzed a "delayed payment" claim as a "short payment" case, never actually answering MMTC's real claim. For another, the tribunal excused the respondents from repaying credit merely because MMTC hadn't collected returned goods, ignoring MMTC's independent contractual right to demand repayment regardless. The order requiring MMTC to return the title deeds was also set aside, since it was based on the now-overturned conclusion that MMTC owed nothing.
Lesson Learnt
When arbitrators reject a claim for the wrong reason, answering a question nobody asked, or ignoring a party's independent contractual right, a court can strike down just that specific part of the award, even decades later, without reopening properly reasoned parts.