M/S Royal Construction Company Pvt. Ltd. v. M/S National Projects Construction Corporation
Background
The award-holder won a 2002 international arbitration award, upheld by the Supreme Court in 2015. Execution dragged on for over two decades amid disputes over currency-conversion dates and, later, a claim that the principal sum had already been paid and withdrawn. The Delhi High Court sent the parties back to the Supreme Court for "clarification" on this factual dispute.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court held the High Court misunderstood the limited scope of its earlier ruling, which answered only a certified legal question, not factual disputes like whether money was already paid. The Court cannot be used as a supervisory authority over ongoing execution proceedings in the guise of "clarification"; those factual questions belong to the executing court. The Court also formally asked the Law Commission of India to study reforms to the arbitral award execution framework, noting with concern that this 2002 award remained unresolved 24 years later.
Lesson Learnt
Winning an arbitration award is only half the battle: enforcement can take decades if courts don't stay within their proper roles; once the Supreme Court answers a specific legal question, parties cannot keep returning to it for factual rulings that belong to the executing court.