Nareshi Devi vs. Union of India
Background
In 2015, a passenger travelling with his family felt unwell, went to the compartment's gate to vomit, and fell from the moving train when it jerked, resulting in his death. The Railway Claims Tribunal denied compensation, concluding he had either acted negligently or deliberately jumped due to his mental state.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held that a passenger's family is entitled to no-fault compensation unless the death was due to the passenger's own deliberate or criminal act: mere carelessness is not enough. The suggestion that he "jumped due to his mental state" was based only on hearsay relayed through an unexamined gate man, not direct evidence. Even if he could have used a washbasin instead of the gate, that showed carelessness at most, not intentional self-harm. The Tribunal's decision was set aside and the case remanded for compensation to be calculated and paid.
Lesson Learnt
Families of railway accident victims are entitled to compensation unless there is real proof, not hearsay, that the victim deliberately caused their own death.