Nareshi Devi vs. Union of India

First Appeal from Order · CNR not assigned (FAO 191/2016)Decided 27 Oct 2026New Delhi Bench
FAO 191/2016
Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri

Background

In 2015, a passenger travelling with his family felt unwell, went to the compartment's gate to vomit, and fell from the moving train when it jerked, resulting in his death. The Railway Claims Tribunal denied compensation, concluding he had either acted negligently or deliberately jumped due to his mental state.

Decision Breakdown

The Court held that a passenger's family is entitled to no-fault compensation unless the death was due to the passenger's own deliberate or criminal act: mere carelessness is not enough. The suggestion that he "jumped due to his mental state" was based only on hearsay relayed through an unexamined gate man, not direct evidence. Even if he could have used a washbasin instead of the gate, that showed carelessness at most, not intentional self-harm. The Tribunal's decision was set aside and the case remanded for compensation to be calculated and paid.

Lesson Learnt

Families of railway accident victims are entitled to compensation unless there is real proof, not hearsay, that the victim deliberately caused their own death.

Consumer RightsDelhi High Court

Smt. Sushma Tyagi vs. M/s HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company Limited, Through its Director & Ors.

The Court first held that a writ petition (a direct petition to the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution) could be filed against this private insurer, because it performs a public duty by insuring the public. On the main issue, the insurer's own case was that both conditions involve a disruption of blood supply to the heart, and both are commonly called a "heart attack", the same words the policy uses. An insurer that denies a claim must prove the event falls outside cover, and HDFC Ergo had not done so. Applying the rule of "contra proferentem" (an unclear term in a contract is read against the party that wrote it) and the purpose of a loan protection policy, the Court held that cardiac arrest falls within "Myocardial Infarction" here. It also set aside the Ombudsman's award because the Ombudsman had to decide the complaint once mediation failed, and did not. The insurer was ordered to pay Rs. 27,97,445 (the husband's 50% share of the sum insured) with 9% yearly interest from 3 July 2021, plus Rs. 5,08,176 towards the loan interest the widow paid on that share, and the further interest on that portion until payment.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Consumer RightsDelhi High Court

Mohd. Ahmad vs. Union of India

The High Court set aside the Tribunal's decision. Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Union of India v. Rina Devi, it said the claimant must first show the person was a genuine passenger, after which the burden shifts to the Railways, and the absence of a recovered ticket is not decisive by itself. The Tribunal had treated the mismatch in the witness's timing as fatal without examining the ticket numbers in the railway's own CRIS verification, which showed tickets issued from Chandigarh that day. It also ignored a Railway Protection Force report saying a ticket was seized from the body, and leaned on the railway inquiry report under Section 123(c) of the Railways Act, 1989 without weighing the post-mortem and inquest material. The matter was sent back to the Tribunal, which was asked to assess the compensation payable and have it paid within two months, with the case listed before the Tribunal on 16 December 2026.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Consumer RightsDelhi High Court

Saroj Devi & Ors. vs. Union of India

The Court held that the death was an "untoward incident" under Section 123(c) of the Railways Act, 1989. The earliest railway record, the Station Master's memo, said a person had fallen from the train, and the Supreme Court's ruling in Union of India v. Rina Devi says an accidental fall while boarding or getting off a train, even from the wrong side, counts as an untoward incident. Carelessness is not the same as a "self-inflicted injury", which needs an intentional act. On the ticket, the Court held that a missing ticket does not by itself defeat a claim: the son's evidence that he saw his father buy the ticket, together with the ticket details verified in the railway's own inquiry, was enough to shift the burden to the Railways, which offered no solid rebuttal. The Court set aside the Tribunal's judgment and sent the case back to fix the compensation and have it paid within two months, listing it before the Tribunal on 3 December 2026.

Decided 17 Nov 2026Read case
Consumer RightsDelhi High Court

Mazhar Khan vs. Union of India

The Court first accepted his request to excuse a 747-day delay in filing the appeal, given his poverty, lack of education, serious injuries and the welfare purpose of the law. On the merits, it applied the Supreme Court's ruling in Union of India v. Rina Devi: a missing ticket does not by itself defeat a claim, and once the injured person gives the basic facts of the trip, for example in a sworn statement, the burden shifts to the Railways. Here the original ticket was on record and the Railways had itself verified that it was issued at Deoband. The Railways' version rested on a statement by a shunting master who was never brought before the Tribunal to be questioned, and Khan was never confronted in cross-examination (questioning by the other side) with the Railways' story about the other train. The Court set aside the Tribunal's judgment, allowed the appeal and sent the case back to the Tribunal only to work out the compensation and have it paid within two months, with the matter listed before the Tribunal on 3 December 2026.

Decided 17 Nov 2026Read case
Consumer RightsDelhi High Court

Rani Devi vs. Union of India

The Court held lack of a physical ticket can't defeat her claim where railway records (a station superintendent's memo, the train manager's statement) independently confirmed a woman fell from that train at that station. The "jumped deliberately" theory was an unproven inference, and negligence differs legally from deliberate self-inflicted injury. The dismissal was overturned and remanded for compensation.

Decided 30 Oct 2026Read case
Consumer RightsDelhi High Court

Devdutt & Ors. vs. Union of India

The Court held absence of a ticket doesn't by itself disprove genuine passenger status: the burden shifts to the Railways to disprove it. The evidence proved a train-related injury but not that he was crossing the tracks rather than falling from a moving train, and the five-years-late inquiry report carried little weight since Railways can't benefit from its own delay. The dismissal was set aside and remanded for compensation calculation.

Decided 30 Oct 2026Read case
Nareshi Devi vs. Union of India – Case Summary