Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd. v. Parsa Kente Collieries Ltd.
Background
Rajasthan's state power-generation company (RVUNL) was allotted the Parsa East and Kanta Basan coal block, and under a 2008 Coal Mining and Delivery Agreement a joint-venture company, Parsa Kente Collieries Ltd. (PKCL), was to mine and deliver coal to RVUNL's power plants. When the Supreme Court cancelled 204 coal-block allocations in 2014, the block was re-allotted to RVUNL under the Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act, 2015, and the contract was continued through a 2016 Supplementary Agreement; PKCL then paid about Rs. 83.48 crore in stamp duty and charges for a fresh mining lease, among other expenses. PKCL raised nine claims in arbitration, and a retired judge as sole arbitrator awarded most of them (including Rs. 71.78 crore for rejected coal rakes, Rs. 83.48 crore stamp duty, Rs. 66.70 crore extra land-acquisition costs in an additional award, and 11.95% simple interest). A Jaipur Commercial Court set both awards aside entirely, but the Rajasthan High Court restored them, and RVUNL appealed to the Supreme Court.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court dismissed RVUNL's petition and left both arbitral awards intact. Going claim by claim, it found no "patent illegality" (an error going to the root and visible on the face of the award) or perversity (a finding based on no evidence, irrelevant material, or ignoring vital evidence) in the arbitrator's findings, which were plausible readings of the contract, and held that the Commercial Court had overstepped by substituting its own interpretation, for instance of the force majeure/"change in law" clause on the stamp-duty claim. It also held the Commercial Court was wrong to throw out the Rs. 66.70 crore additional award on limitation (time-bar) grounds when RVUNL had never raised limitation before the arbitrator, since limitation is a mixed question of fact and law that depends on pleadings and evidence. Because no part of the awards was invalid, the questions of severing parts of the award or sending the matter back did not arise; the Court stressed that its Article 136 power in arbitration matters is to be used only sparingly.
Lesson Learnt
Courts reviewing an arbitration award do not re-decide the case: if the arbitrator's reading of the contract is a possible one, it stands even if a judge would have read it differently. Objections such as a claim being time-barred must be raised before the arbitrator; they generally cannot be raised for the first time when challenging the award in court.