Regional Provident Fund Commissioner-II v. Mamta Binani & Ors.

Civil Appeal · 2026 INSC 1003Decided 10 Sept 2026
Civil Appeal arising out of Diary No. 42931 of 2026
Justice Dipankar Datta · Justice Sheel Nagu

Background

The NCLT approved a resolution plan for Rolta India Limited on 15 December 2025. The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, aggrieved by this approval, tried to e-file an appeal before the NCLAT starting from 28 January 2026, one day before the outer condonable limit (30 days + 15 days grace) under Section 61(2) of the IBC expired, but the NCLAT's own e-filing portal suffered a technical/OTP glitch that prevented filing on both 28 and 29 January. The appeal was finally e-filed on 30 January 2026, one day beyond the maximum permissible period, and the NCLAT dismissed the condonation application and the appeal itself as time-barred, holding it had no power to condone delay beyond the statutory 45-day outer limit.

Decision Breakdown

The Supreme Court agreed that the NCLAT correctly read Section 61(2) as allowing no condonation beyond 45 days, and that its own precedents (National Spot Exchange, Tata Steel) were correctly stated but factually distinguishable since those cases involved litigant fault, not tribunal system failure. Here, the delay was caused entirely by a backend/OTP failure in the NCLAT's own e-filing system, as confirmed by the NCLAT Registry's own report. Invoking the principle "actus curiae neminem gravabit" (an act of the court shall harm no one), the Court held that limitation runs against a litigant only when the court/tribunal's own systems are actually capable of receiving filings; when the tribunal's system itself fails, the litigant should not be penalised. It set aside the NCLAT's order and restored the appeal for fresh consideration, directing that the date of the first bona fide e-filing attempt be treated as the date of presentation.

Lesson Learnt

Even a rigid statutory limitation deadline cannot be used to shut a litigant out when the delay is proven to be caused by a failure of the court or tribunal's own filing system, not the litigant's fault. Courts can exempt such periods from limitation computation under the "actus curiae neminem gravabit" principle.

Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

ECL Finance Ltd. and Anr. v. Abhinav Mukherjee and Ors. (with connected matters)

The Supreme Court upheld the exclusion, holding the "related party" threshold is lower than the control test used for resolution-applicant eligibility: merely having a genuine role in the debtor's policy-making is enough. The lender held sweeping powers (appointing directors, control over budgets and unit sales, control over escrow accounts) going well beyond passive creditor protections. The Court also rejected a late assignment of the loan to another entity as a bona-fide transfer, finding it was made only to circumvent the related-party bar after insolvency proceedings had already begun.

Decided 27 Oct 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

Bank of India & Ors. v. S.M. Kamal Pasha & Ors.

The Supreme Court upheld the appellate tribunal's ruling that creditors cannot unilaterally withdraw an already-approved Resolution Plan merely because the debtor's fortunes later improved: once approved and placed before the Tribunal, the plan becomes binding under the IBC's statutory framework, not ordinary contract law, and the withdrawal route applies only before approval, not after. The Court left it to the Tribunal to decide both the winning bidder's confirmation request and the promoters' competing settlement application on the merits.

Decided 26 Oct 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

Deepak Raheja and Another v. Omkara Assets Reconstruction Private Ltd. and Another

The Supreme Court dismissed both appeals, holding that a tribunal need only find a summary, prima facie default, not conduct a full forensic audit, with detailed quantification left for the later claims-verification process. A default authenticated with an official "Information Utility" debt registry is normally sufficient proof, rebuttable only by strong evidence, not bare denials. The Court held a company's accounting profitability is legally irrelevant to whether it can service debt as payments fall due; the real test is actual cash availability, and here the company was covering only about 12% of its obligations. The Court separately flagged that the appellants' lawyers had filed a compilation of case citations containing AI-generated, non-existent judgments, recording it as an "undesirable incident" (no costs imposed only because the lead appellant had since died).

Decided 15 Oct 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

The Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax, CGST Division v. Sreenivasa Rao Ravinuthala & Anr.

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal solely on limitation grounds. Under Section 62 IBC, an appeal must be filed within 45 days (extendable by at most 15 more days): an absolute 60-day ceiling courts cannot extend further. The Court rejected the Department's argument that the clock should start only upon receiving the certified copy, holding that limitation runs from the order's pronouncement, and only actual certified-copy processing time (not any delay before applying for it) is excluded. The Department had waited 35 days before even applying for the certified copy, pushing it well past the ceiling.

Decided 14 Oct 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawDelhi High Court

M/S Meena Steels Limited vs. Punjab National Bank

The Court held that Section 125(2)(h) applies to money received by a company for allotment of securities, not to a refund arising from a court-sanctioned reduction of share capital, so the Bank's reliance on it was misplaced. Since the earlier orders had already been passed after considering the material on record and no error apparent on the face of the record was shown, the Court found no ground for review and dismissed the Bank's petition.

Decided 8 Oct 2026Read case
Company & Insolvency LawSupreme Court of India

Greenopolis Welfare Confederation v. Rakesh Kumar Gupta

The Supreme Court held that once an insolvency petition is admitted, the proceedings become proceedings "in rem" affecting all creditors and stakeholders, not just the original applicant, so the original applicant cannot simply withdraw, but if fraud and collusion are found, the Adjudicating Authority (AA) can and should disallow that fraudulent applicant from continuing, while deciding separately whether the wider insolvency process itself should still continue to protect other genuine stakeholders like homebuyers. The Court allowed this appeal in part, set aside the NCLAT's blanket recall of the entire CIRP, and restored the insolvency proceedings to the Adjudicating Authority, directing it to now decide afresh, after hearing the resolution professional, the committee of creditors, and the homebuyers, whether the CIRP should continue in view of the confirmed fraud, and to do so expeditiously given how long the case has run.

Decided 30 Sept 2026Read case