Shakeel Qureshi & Ors. vs. Rashid Qureshi & Ors.
Background
Family members holding 50% of a food company's shares signed an MOU requiring any sale to first be offered within the group, with disputes going exclusively to Bareilly courts. One member agreed to sell shares to a relative on condition the buyer wouldn't resell outside the family, but the buyer allegedly auctioned the shares to an outsider. The plaintiffs sued in Delhi; the single judge returned the plaint for lack of jurisdiction.
Decision Breakdown
The Division Bench agreed Delhi had no jurisdiction. Since the plaintiffs' case was built on the MOU's rights and obligations, they couldn't enforce its share-transfer restrictions while ignoring its Bareilly jurisdiction clause. One defendant living in Delhi, or unrelated family lawsuits pending there, did not by itself create jurisdiction. The appeal was dismissed, with liberty to refile in Bareilly.
Lesson Learnt
If a contract names a specific city's courts, a person suing to enforce rights under that contract generally cannot shop for a more convenient court: the jurisdiction clause binds you along with everything else in the agreement.