Shreeram Builders v. Upendra Kantilal Thanawala & Ors.
Background
A builder entered a 2003 development agreement with landowners to develop their share of a Thane plot in exchange for staggered payments. When the owners terminated the agreement in 2008 alleging default, an arbitral tribunal in 2011 sided with the builder, treating the agreement as effectively a sale agreement and ordering the owners to execute a sale deed. The Bombay High Court set this award aside in 2024.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court upheld setting aside the award, though for more precise reasons, holding that stamp duty classification alone wasn't decisive, but the arbitrators had exceeded their authority by effectively rewriting the contract: the price was never fixed, full consideration was never paid by deadline, and the arbitrators invented an unexplained price multiplier and damages the contract never provided for. Invoking its Article 142 power to do complete justice, the Court ordered the owners to refund all amounts received from the builder with 9% interest, since they never returned the payments after terminating the deal.
Lesson Learnt
Arbitrators must decide strictly within the contract's terms and the law: they cannot rewrite agreed terms or invent new remedies, since doing so renders the award void; separately, a party that keeps the other side's money after terminating a contract cannot hold it interest-free indefinitely.