South Bihar Power Distribution Company Ltd. v. India Power Corporation Ltd. & Anr. (with connected appeal)
Background
A power-distribution franchise dispute's arbitration clause called for a three-member tribunal, but the parties consented to a sole arbitrator for years without objection. When the franchisee's subsidiary went through insolvency and the arbitration overran its statutory deadline, disputes arose over whether the High Court could extend the sole arbitrator's mandate and whether the insolvency moratorium blocked the arbitration.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court held the appellant's years of unobjected participation with a sole arbitrator amounted to a clear waiver of its right to insist on a three-member tribunal. It held the insolvency moratorium doesn't stop a debtor's own subsidiary from pursuing a recovery claim that benefits its creditors. On jurisdiction, it agreed the power to extend an arbitrator's mandate belongs only to the ordinary civil court, not the High Court acting in its arbitrator-appointment capacity, though this error was moot since a civil court had independently already granted the extension.
Lesson Learnt
Consenting to or participating in arbitration that departs from your contract's terms without prompt objection is treated as a waiver you cannot reverse years later; separately, only the ordinary civil court, not the High Court's arbitrator-appointment jurisdiction, can extend an arbitrator's statutory time limit.