Sumit Kumar v. Union of India
Background
Sumit Kumar, a CISF constable since 2012, took leave in late 2017 because his wife suffered a fourth miscarriage and needed major surgeries. When further leave was refused in December 2017, he submitted a "conditional" resignation under acute stress, and a video of his wife accusing his superiors of harassment was circulated. He was charged with disobeying an order to appear before the Commandant, pressuring the administration, intimidating officers through relatives and circulating the video, and with having five earlier minor penalties; after an inquiry he was removed from service on 1 May 2018, and the Delhi High Court upheld the removal, calling him a "habitual offender."
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed the appeals and quashed the removal, finding no written direction or other reliable proof that he was ordered to appear and deliberately disobeyed, and no evidence linking him to the video (which was recorded at the hospital while he was at his unit) or to any threats by relatives: a person cannot be punished merely for being related to someone who misbehaved. Past penalties already suffered cannot themselves be a fresh charge or fill gaps in proof, though they may be relevant to sentencing for a separately proved misconduct. The inquiry was also unfair: the English documents were translated into Hindi for him only after all witnesses had been examined, and he was denied a defence assistant. Even taking the resignation episode at face value, removal from service was "shockingly disproportionate" given his wife's medical crisis; the Court ordered immediate reinstatement with all consequential benefits and 50% back wages, without a fresh inquiry.
Lesson Learnt
Even in a disciplined force, an employee can only be punished for misconduct actually proved against him in a fair inquiry, which includes giving him documents in a language he understands in time to defend himself. Courts will strike down a punishment that is so harsh it shocks the conscience, especially where the employee acted under genuine family distress.