T. Akon Phom v. State of Nagaland
Background
In April 2025, Nagaland's Excise Department advertised 40 (later 46) Excise Constable posts, with the selection process described as a Physical Test followed by a Suitability Test/Viva-Voce. After 11,521 applications came in, the Departmental Recruitment Board issued a corrigendum on 4 June 2025 adding a 100-mark written exam at Class VIII level. Some candidates challenged this mid-way change; a Single Judge of the Gauhati High Court (Kohima Bench) quashed the corrigendum, but a Division Bench reversed that ruling in June 2026, and the 46 selected candidates were notified on 29 June 2026.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court dismissed the candidates' appeal and upheld the Division Bench. It held that the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999 allow direct recruitment by "competitive examination/selection," so a Class VIII-level written exam was within the Rules, and a 2016 departmental memorandum relied upon by the candidates had never been notified or strictly enforced. The advertisement itself allowed the Board to issue corrigenda and make binding decisions, the change was widely publicised in local newspapers, and every candidate who cleared the physical test faced the same written exam. The Court added that an objective written test is a fairer way to shortlist from a huge pool than relying mainly on a subjective interview, and the candidates, most of whom took part in the process knowing of the change, showed no discrimination or prejudice.
Lesson Learnt
Where recruitment rules do not lay down a detailed procedure, the recruiting authority has room to add a fair, objective screening step such as a written exam, provided it is publicised and applied equally to all candidates. Candidates who take part in a revised process without objection will find it hard to challenge it later just because they were not selected.