Visa Worldwide Pte Limited vs. PayU Payments Private Limited and Ors
Background
PayU, an online payment aggregator, sued several banks and Visa in the Delhi High Court. ICICI Bank had complained to Visa that some merchants handled through PayU were given the wrong Merchant Category Code (MCC, a 4-digit code showing a merchant's line of business), which reduced the card fees it received. Visa was deciding these claims through its own private compliance process, and Yes Bank had already deducted money from PayU's escrow account (a ring-fenced account holding customers' payments). PayU, which said it does not assign MCCs and was not part of Visa's process, feared further deductions. On 14 September 2026, a Single Judge asked the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to mediate within 30 days and ordered all sides to keep things as they were meanwhile, so Visa could not issue final decisions and the banks could not make further deductions. Visa appealed.
Decision Breakdown
Visa argued that PayU's suit should not have been entertained because it skipped pre-institution mediation, which Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 makes compulsory before filing a commercial suit unless urgent interim relief is sought. The Division Bench held that a plaintiff satisfies Section 12A by seeking urgent interim relief in the plaint, and no separate exemption application has to be allowed first, though the court must check the urgency plea is not a sham. Here the Single Judge had noted PayU's risk of civil and criminal liability if its escrow balance fell too low, which was enough. Relying on the Supreme Court's Dhanbad Fuels ruling, the Court said a court may refer parties to mediation even after a suit is filed, and the RBI was acting as a mediator, not as the adjudicator under Section 24 of the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007. Keeping the position frozen during mediation was a natural step so mediation would not become pointless. Since an appeal against an interim order interferes only where the lower court erred on principle, the appeal was dismissed.
Lesson Learnt
In a commercial dispute, a party seeking genuinely urgent interim relief may go to court without first attempting compulsory pre-suit mediation, and courts can still send the dispute to mediation later. When that happens, a court can order both sides to keep matters as they are so the mediation has a fair chance.