Girishbhai Natwarlal Patel v. Gautam Punjabhai Palkhiwala (Dead) by LRs & Ors.
Background
A plot of land passed through a chain of sale deeds to a cooperative housing society under a 2013 consent decree for specific performance, then to the appellant via a court-commissioner sale in 2022. In 2023, a family who had earlier held rights over the land discovered the transfer and alleged the appellant had represented both sides of the original 2013 suit. They sought, nearly 11 years after the decree, condonation of delay, leave to appeal as non-parties, and an interim injunction, all of which the Gujarat High Court granted.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court upheld the High Court on all three points. The interim injunction was valid even though granted before the delay and leave applications were decided, given the suspicious circumstances and risk the land could be sold off. On maintainability, the Court clarified that the usual bar on appealing a consent decree binds only those who were parties to the compromise: it doesn't stop a genuinely aggrieved outsider whose own rights are prejudiced. On delay, since the family only learned of the decree's effect on their rights in 2023 and acted promptly thereafter, condonation was proper. The Court decided only these procedural questions, directing the High Court to resolve the underlying fraud allegations within three months.
Lesson Learnt
A consent decree binds only the people who actually agreed to it: someone who was never a party but can show their own property rights are genuinely and directly hurt by it can still get court permission to challenge it, with delay counted from when they actually discovered the harm.