Somnath Kharbanda (deceased, through LRs) & Anr. vs. Arvinder Kaur (deceased, through LRs) & Ors.
Background
In 2008, Arvinder Kaur agreed to buy a property from the Kharbanda brothers for Rs 40 lakh and paid Rs 4 lakh as earnest money. She later refused to pay the remaining Rs 36 lakh, claiming the sellers never produced title documents for verification. She sued for double the earnest money back; the sellers claimed she simply defaulted and that they were entitled to forfeit the deposit, having themselves lost money on a related deal because of her default. The trial court ordered a refund of the original Rs 4 lakh with interest.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court held that under Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, forfeiting an earnest-money deposit is not automatic: the party keeping the money must prove it actually suffered a genuine, provable loss. The sellers' claimed loss on another property deal went unproven at trial (originals never produced, no corroborating testimony). Since the sellers failed to prove any actual loss, they had no legal basis to keep the deposit, and the appeal was dismissed.
Lesson Learnt
If you want to keep a deposit after a deal falls through, pointing to a contract clause isn't enough: you must prove with real evidence that you actually suffered a loss because of the other side's breach.